US National Security Agency: NSA lost hacking tools to China already in 2016

Just one year before The Shadow Brokers released the NSA hacking tools, Buckeye hackers used similar software to attack. The group is assigned to the Chinese Ministry of State Security.

US National Security Agency: NSA lost hacking tools to China already in 2016
US National Security Agency: NSA lost hacking tools to China already in 2016

According to reports by security firm Symantec, the US National Security Agency (NSA) has already lost hacking tools to a state-owned hacker group in 2016. The software comes from the fund of the NSA hacking department Equation Group. They are said to have been used by the Advanced Persistant Threat (APT) Buckeye, which is assigned to the Chinese Ministry of State Security, since 2016 against targets in Europe and Asia. In 2017 similar tools were released by the hacker group The Shadow Brokers.

Read More Stories: Guido blames social media for his decision to abandon the supervision of Python

Buckeye is said to have used the NSA backdoor Doublepulsar against targets in Hong Kong, Belgium, Luxembourg, Vietnam and the Philippines. There is no evidence that the US has been attacked by its intelligence programs, according to the report. Symantec suspects that the attackers believed that the US had either developed protective measures against the in-house tools or simply did not want to be exposed.

Read More Stories: REACT NATIVE: Microsoft switches to C++ for Javascript apps from C#

The Doublepulsar version used by Buckeye differed from the version published in April by The Shadow Brokers: they had newer versions of Windows and additional camouflage features, Symantec writes in the investigation. According to Symantec, the changes could well have come from the malware’s NSA authors.

China and the NSA tools

How Buckeye, which is also called Gothic Panda, Threat Group-0110 or simply APT3, before the leak by The Shadow Brokers could get to the NSA tools is unknown. Symantec speculates that Buckeye may have rebuilt the software from traces left by an NSA attack. But you could also simply come from a badly secured server of the Equation Group or have been lost in an attack.

Read More Stories: Cortana will be more natural and conversational thanks to changes in machine learning by Microsoft

The assignment of hacker attacks, especially to APTs, is a complex undertaking. Symantec assumes that it is the Chinese APT due to the combination of the NSA backdoor Doublepulsar with Buckeye’s typical malware such as Pirpi. Symantec has since the release of Buckeye by the US in 2017, no activity of the hacker group more, but the NSA malware has continued to be used. Symantec speculates that Buckeye has redistributed tools to another group in China or could continue to work with new tools

However, the case can also be seen as further evidence of the complexity of assigning attacks: if the attackers use stolen tools from other APTs or monitor hackers and take over their programs and attack techniques, this makes the assignment more difficult. This is usually based on clues such as the tools used, the timestamps in the software, the actions of the attackers or the agenda of the respective country.

Read More Stories: Armageddon 2027: Is there any salvation from asteroids?

Previous articleREACT NATIVE: Microsoft switches to C++ for Javascript apps from C#
Next articleRED HAT: RHEL 8 Appears with Appstreams and Basic Image for All
Aakash Molpariya
Aakash started in Nov 2018 as a writer at Since joining, as writer, he is mainly responsible for Software, Science, programming, system administration and the Technology ecosystem, but due to his versatility he is used for everything possible. He writes about topics ranging from AI to hardware to games, stands in front of and behind the camera, creates creative product images and much more. He is a trained IT systems engineer and has studied computer science. By the way, he is enthusiastic about his own small projects in game development, hardware-handicraft, digital art, gaming and music. Email: aakash (at) revyuh (dot) com